print logo
RSS FEED

America Is Not Declining

Wednesday, December 3, 2008

Demographic and economic trends suggest that the age of American dominance won’t end anytime soon.

Barack Obama and the next Congress will take power at a time when the financial crisis and Mesopotamian misadventures have spurred talk of America’s decline. Last week, a Russian analyst was even giddily forecasting the collapse and breakup of the United States, with Russia and China becoming joint global hegemons. Such predictions may comfort critics and opponents of American power, but they lack any real basis. In fact, long-term demographic and economic trends suggest that the age of American dominance won’t end anytime soon.

In Futurecast (St. Martin’s Press, $26.95), economist Robert Shapiro, a founder of the Progressive Policy Institute and now chairman of the consulting firm Sonecon, examines how the relentless forces of demographics and globalization will shape the world of 2020. His analysis suggests that the United States will remain the leading global power. Europe, Japan, and China, meanwhile, have reason to worry.

Demographic trends will have seismic effects on the world’s economies and may even spur domestic conflicts over dwindling resources. Indeed, Shapiro cautions that much of the world is about to confront “the greatest aging of national populations ever seen, along with the smallest relative numbers of working-age people on record.”

In Europe and Japan, where labor forces are already shrinking, fewer workers will have to pay more taxes to support the growing pensioner population, triggering a vicious economic cycle.

In Europe and Japan, where labor forces are already shrinking, fewer workers will have to pay more taxes to support the growing pensioner population, triggering a vicious economic cycle. Workers will have less money to save. That will mean less investment, which will translate into slower productivity growth and sluggish income progress, making it ever harder for the fewer workers to support the pensions of more seniors.

China will face similar challenges. Thanks to its notorious one-child policy, it has the world’s most rapidly aging population: between 2005 and 2020, the number of Chinese aged 65 and over will grow by 65 percent. China does not offer much government support for its elderly, which may lead to unrest, particularly among seniors living in urban centers such as Beijing and Shanghai.

The United States faces a more encouraging demographic future. To be sure, it will need to make adjustments and reform its entitlement programs. But America has maintained higher fertility rates than the countries of Europe and Japan, and its population has been rejuvenated by two generations of high immigration.

Between 2008 and 2020, globalization will continue spreading prosperity around the world, expanding consumer choice, and intensifying competition throughout domestic markets. Over the past 30 years, trade and investment between countries has expanded twice as fast as the total growth and investment of all individual countries. Developing countries are now able to attract the capital to build modern factories and businesses.

Globalization will also transform services, which represent two-thirds of advanced economies. It is a sign of the times that even lawyers may lose their jobs to outsourcing, with Indian firms such as Pangea3 providing basic legal research and drafting services at (what Pangea3 calls) “a radically low cost.”

Between 2005 and 2020, the number of Chinese aged 65 and over will grow by 65 percent.

In all likelihood, the United States will continue doing well in the white heat of international competition, while the highly regulated economies of continental Europe and Japan will stumble. Barring a departure from open markets, the vast and flexible U.S. economy will remain a magnet for investment that funds innovation, which will ensure that U.S. workers remain among the most productive and highly paid in the world.

America will also benefit from deeper engagement with developing countries, the markets of the future. Twenty-seven percent of U.S. foreign direct investment (FDI) is in developing countries, which is three to five times the share of British, French, and German FDI in those countries. America’s close links with the developing world will help make its businesses integral to future global economic growth.

China is also poised to take advantage of globalization. Its large domestic market and low-wage workforce will continue attracting investment. Yet China faces monumental challenges that go well beyond an aging population; it also must reform its rickety financial and legal systems, repair its decrepit infrastructure, and shrink the large state footprint in its business sector. Shapiro believes it is an open question whether the China of 2020 will be an economic power with global pretensions or a poor country serving as a manufacturing platform for foreign businesses.

What about Russia and India? Russia is a poor country with a rapidly aging population and a bleak future. The productivity of Russian workers is lower than that of workers in Botswana. Russian experts project that over the next 15 years, Russia’s working-age population could collapse by 14 percent to 25 percent.

The United States faces a more encouraging demographic future.

As for India, Shapiro reckons it will remain a small player in the global economy, at least in the short run. India accounted for less than one percent of global exports between 2000 and 2003. There are various bright spots in the Indian economy, but it is difficult to see how the country can become a major player until it fixes its dismal infrastructure and loosens its suffocating regulations.

For all these reasons and more, it is premature to write an obituary for the era of American dominance. The financial crisis has been a blow to near-term U.S. economic growth, and there is no question that America’s healthcare, pension, and education systems all require serious reforms. But despite these problems, the United States will almost certainly remain the world’s dominant power, thanks mainly to the openness, flexibility, and dynamism of its economy.

Rod Hunter, a Hudson Institute senior fellow and Washington lawyer, served as a National Security Council senior director under President George W. Bush.

Image by Darren Wamboldt/Bergman Group.

Most Viewed Articles

Science vs. PR By Robert McHenry 05/11/2012
How a piece of journeyman work is turned into patently junk science.
Why We Need Principles-Based Regulation By Arnold Kling 05/22/2012
Instead of regulating the boundaries between what is approved and what is forbidden, perhaps we ...
Public-Sector Pensions: The Transition Costs Myth By Andrew G. Biggs 05/21/2012
Public-sector employees and the pension industrial complex are using deceptive and self-serving ...
The Future Will Be More Religious and Conservative Than You Think By Eric Kaufmann 05/08/2012
Population change is reversing secularism and shifting the center of gravity of entire societies in ...
The Hayek Effect: The Political Consequences of Planned Austerity By Lee Harris 05/17/2012
Why the political revolt in Greece may not be a fluke, but a harbinger of more revolts to come.
 
AEI