print logo
RSS FEED

The Limits of Blaming Bush

Saturday, February 6, 2010

In his latest budget request, President Obama added roughly $1.6 trillion in spending over the next ten years on top of what he requested last year. Can President Obama blame that extra $1.6 trillion on former President Bush?

President Obama has been in the White House for more than a year now, but he hasn’t yet gotten tired of telling the American people that the terrible fiscal outlook is the product of the Bush administration’s policies. This is an excerpt from his budget message released on Monday (see p. 3): "On the day my administration took office, we faced an additional $7.5 trillion in national debt by the end of this decade as a result of the failure to pay for two large tax cuts, primarily for the wealthiest Americans, and a new entitlement program. We also inherited the worst recession since the Great Depression—which, even before we took any action, added an additional $3 trillion to the national debt."

The Bush-era deficits were bad. I spent a great deal of time in the last eight years protesting our last president’s lack of fiscal responsibility (here and here, for instance). And yes, a large part of the fiscal 2009 deficit was the result of policies instituted by Bush during his last year in office.

But those are hardly reasons to keep adding to the deficit.

Using data in President Obama’s budget request for fiscal 2010 and data from the fiscal 2011 budget request, the following chart projects spending each year from fiscal 2010 until fiscal 2019. The purple bars represent the spending amounts the president requested in February 2009. The orange bars represent the growth in the projected spending request between February 2009 and February 2010.

In his latest budget request, President Obama added roughly $1.6 trillion in spending over the next ten years on top of what he requested last year. Can President Obama blame that extra $1.6 trillion on former President Bush?

de Rugy 2.5.10

To be sure, the president's new budget data admits to a gigantic deficit in fiscal 2010. But it insists that smaller deficits are in our future. In fact, the president projects that the deficit will shrink to $700 billion in fiscal 2013.

I would take these projections with a grain of salt. Again, in February 2009, President Obama projected that the deficit for fiscal 2010 would be $1.2 trillion (Table S-1). This year, we find out that the deficit for fiscal 2010 will actually reach $1.6 trillion (Table S-1). And spending, which was projected to go down in fiscal 2010 to $3.6 trillion from its $3.9 trillion fiscal 2009 level, will climb by an estimated 6 percent by the end of the fiscal year to $3.7 trillion.

Overall, the president might have inherited a large deficit. But he has been adding to it as fast as he possibly can.

Veronique de Rugy is a senior research fellow at The Mercatus Center at George Mason University.

FURTHER READING: De Rugy regularly illustrates the follies of government spending for THE AMERICAN. She recently asked, “So How Is the Stimulus Working Out?” and has explained “The High Cost of No Price” for healthcare. “Why Reform Will Cost Taxpayers More, Much More” looks at some of our recent cost overruns in government-driven medical spending. The author explains the “State of the Stimulus,” how “The Jobs Picture Crashes Into Debt Realities,” and offers “A Peek Inside the Deficit.” And the American Enterprise Institute’s John Makin reviewed the U.S. economy and government policy in “Post-Crisis Risks.”

Image by Darren Wamboldt/Bergman Group.

Most Viewed Articles

‘The American Banking System Might Not Last Until Monday’ By Alex J. Pollock 08/23/2014
Learning from the crises you’ve forgotten.
The Truth, Probably By Robert McHenry 08/31/2014
We will never attain certainty about our concerns, but with care and luck we approach it by ...
Peanut Butter’s Many Inventors By Edward Tenner 08/15/2014
The popular product illustrates both the opportunities and the risks of intellectual property.
The Long-Hours Luxury By Tino Sanandaji 08/04/2014
One factor that is often overlooked in the debate over causes of income inequality is a shift in ...
A Flawed E-Cigarette Regulation By Sally Satel and Alan D. Viard 08/16/2014
The FDA's proposed regulation should not go forward in its current form, or it will undermine ...
 
AEI