print logo

How Much Have House Prices Really Fallen?

Thursday, April 19, 2012

If we could stop the government’s constriction of private mortgage credit, recovery could begin sooner rather than later.

How much have U.S. house prices fallen since their peak in mid-2006? It depends on whether you measure them in nominal or inflation-adjusted terms. According to the S&P/Case-Shiller National House Price Index, the fall has been about 34 percent. That’s in nominal terms, and that’s a lot. But since inflation has continued, the fall in real terms is even bigger.

Adjusting for Consumer Price Index inflation, the drop in house prices since the peak has been 41 percent. There’s a number nobody predicted! The fall in nominal versus real terms is shown in Graph 1. Going forward, if nominal house prices go sideways for a while, as many believe, while inflation continues, as it will, real house prices will continue going down.

4.18.12 Pollock Graph 1

Graph 2 shows the nominal versus real paths of the house price bubble and bust since 1996. Nominal house prices are back to the level of 2002. But inflation-adjusted house prices have returned all the way to the level of 1999. In other words, after six long years, in real terms the entire bubble has been reversed.

4.18.12 Pollock Graph 2

When combined with rising rents and strong housing affordability, this gives us reasonable hope that we are at last approaching the bottom.

There is one key obstacle remaining, however: The government keeps making it riskier and more expensive to be in the mortgage loan business. As one community banker recently said, “It is probably now impossible to make a loan that might not be deemed illegal in one way or another.” If we could stop the government’s bust-prolonging constriction of private mortgage credit, the cyclical recovery could begin sooner rather than later.

Alex J. Pollock is a resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute.

FURTHER READING: Pollock also writes “Fearful Symmetry: Six Decades of Treasury Yields,” “Waiting for Hamilton: The ‘Imbecility’ of the EU,” “Seven Steps Needed to Improve Housing Finance,” and “Fixing Student Loans: Let’s Give Colleges Some ‘Skin in the Game’.” Peter J. Wallison says “Hey, Barney Frank: The Government Did Cause the Housing Crisis.” Edward J. Pinto contributes “Housing Affordability: U.S. Is the Envy of the Developed World.”

Image by Rob Green / Bergman Group

Most Viewed Articles

Why the Government Won't Let Colleges Reduce Tuition By Ike Brannon 09/17/2014
Congress should give permission for private colleges to cooperate in cutting their tuition. It’s ...
The U-9 and the Realm of the Unexpected By Ralph Kinney Bennett 09/19/2014
Exactly 100 years ago the world was reminded yet again that war — declared or undeclared — is in ...
Closing the Racial Gap in Education By Jason L. Riley 09/10/2014
The usual explanation for the academic achievement gap is that blacks come from a lower ...
Telecommuting: Good for Workers, Good for Bosses By Michael M. Rosen 09/12/2014
Challenges abound, but the trajectory is plain.
The Minimum Wage Can Never Be High Enough By Ike Brannon 09/07/2014
The minimum wage is a facile non-solution for the complicated problem of poverty in America.